
Barry
Lyndon 4K
(1975/Warner/Criterion 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray w/Blu-ray)/Executive
Suite
(1954/MGM*)/His
Kind Of Woman
(1951/RKO/*both Warner Archive Blu-ray)/Rust
(2024/Decal DVD)/Warfare
(2025/A24 Blu-ray)
4K
Ultra HD Picture: A- Picture: B/B/B/C+/B Sound: B-/C+/C+/C+/B
Extras: B+/B/B/D/B Films: A-/B/B/C+/B+
PLEASE
NOTE:
The Executive
Suite
and His
Kind Of Woman
Blu-rays are now only available from Warner Bros. through their
Warner Archive series and can be ordered from the link below.
Next
up are melodramas with advanced, even complex stakes and all worth a
good look and them sone. We'll start with a classic.
Stanley
Kubrick's Barry
Lyndon 4K
(1975) was the film the all-time genius director made when his
Napoleon project collapsed from financial backing pulling out after
the epic Waterloo
bombed at the box office. Not wanting to waste his immense research
on the project and still wanting to make a film about the period, he
chose the William Makepeace Thackeray novel ironically entitled The
Luck Of Barry Lyndon.
It would benefit from some key innovations and remains one of the
greatest epic films ever made.
Warner,
hoping for another Lawrence
Of Arabia-sized
hit, backed it and Kubrick was on a critical and (eventually)
commercial roll. Then big box office star Ryan O'Neal (What's
Up, Doc?,
Paper
Moon,
Love
Story)
was hired to play the title role, with many saying he was all wrong
and not the brawling, angry, drunken, lower-class Irish guy type and
too much a romanic lead to work. Of course, we now know the late
actor was far closer to the character than most knew and is really
good here.
He
marries into wealth and a higher social class and almost immediately,
though in a slower way and period style, leads from one bad situation
to another and sometimes, disaster. Then a war is also going on and
the characters will not be able to allow it to take place in the
background like so many romantic war epics, so the stakes are much
higher for everyone involved and the class division with little
movement is more frail with a war going on.
The
scenes of personal conflict and equally remarkable war sequences
complement each other as the story moves forward, the various and
subtle nuances throughout the film are remarkable, non-stop and just
keep adding to its epic sweep as it builds to its climax. Barry
Lyndon
was sadly not a big hit when it came out, but its influence was
immediate (Ridley Scott's The
Duelists
only a few years later (his first feature film) was one of the first
to show it) and with its ultra-naturalist, ultra-realist approach
that included the way it was shot and items like costumes that no
longer looked like obvious costumes but clothes you would see if you
were back in time permanently marked the end of the old Hollywood way
of almost all epics and a new way that was far more convincing,
compelling, believable and effective.
Running
just over three hours, the cast also includes Marisa Berenson,
Patrick Magee, Leon Vitali, Hardy Kruger, Diana Korner, Steven
Berkoff, Andre Morrell, Philip Stone, Geoffrey Quigley, Roger Booth,
John Bindon, Murray Melvin, Barry Jackson, Ferdy Mayne, George
Sewell, Anthony Sharp, John Sharp and Leonard Rossiteer. Another
great cast!
Special
Features include a high quality booklet with tech info, an essay by
critic Geoffrey O'Brien and two pieces about the look of the film
from the March 1976 issue of American
Cinematographer,
while the discs add...
• Interviews
with the cast and crew as well as archival audio featuring director
Stanley Kubrick on the film's cinematography, costumes, editing, and
production
• Interview
featuring historian Christopher Frayling on production designer Ken
Adam
• Interview
with critic Michel Ciment
• Interview
with actor Leon Vitali about the 5.1 surround soundtrack, which he
co-supervised
• Interview
with curator Adam Eaker about the fine-art-inspired aesthetics of the
film
• and
Trailers.
More
Kubrick films on 4K are also out there, but this is one of the best
and some (2001,
The
Shining)
disappointed me a bit. This one does not. For another one that did
not, try my coverage of A
Clockwork Orange 4K:
https://fulvuedrive-in.com/review/15973/A+Clockwork+Orange+4K+(1971/Kubrick/Warner+4K
Robert
Wise's Executive
Suite
(1954)
has been upgraded to Blu-ray by Warner Archive and is a nice
successor to the old DVD. As I said in my DVD review....
''I
am not a big fan of the work of Robert Wise, but even I have to admit
that his 1953 MGM drama Executive
Suite
is one of his best films. Originally issued as part of the Barbara
Stanwyck Signature Collection
on DVD, which we covered at this link, it deserves this special
reissue:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/6231/Barbara+Stanwyck+Signature+Collecti
A
major executive at a respected manufacturer unexpectedly dies and the
fallout deals with corporate responsibility, in a battle between a
inventor (William Holden) with the company, a bean-counting goof
(Fredric March) who wants to sell the company out for cheap, quick
profits no matter how it permanently damages its name and reputation
and caught in between are the many employees of the company, a
corporate board that is not very united, a widow (Barbara Stanwyck)
too upset to do anything who has also been an absent board member and
Shelley Winters shows up as the secretary who has become a confidant
to a board member without most knowing.
Written
very well by Ernest Lehman (North
By Northwest),
the film holds up very well for its age and is as relevant as ever
[and even years later, as much as ever]. Additional turns by a first
rate cast that includes Walter Pidgeon, Paul Douglas, a young Dean
Jagger, Louis Calhern, Tim Considine and an unusually effective Nina
Foch make this a must-see film not enough have seen.''
Extras
are a little different here than on the DVD and repeat the feature
length audio commentary track on the film, by Oliver Stone that is
pretty thorough about its politics, the time the film was made and
more, then add an Original Theatrical Trailer, Tom & Jerry
animated Technicolor short Hic-Up
Pup
and live action Pete
Smith Specialty
short Do
Someone A favor.
John
Farrow's His
Kind Of Woman
(1951) was originally issued on DVD in a Film Noir 3 box set and at
the time, I said...
''John
Farrow directed one of RKO's most interesting and ambitious Noirs
ever with His
Kind Of Woman from
1951, but it was Richard Fleischer who landed up reshooting almost
the entire thing, though he is not credited for it. It not only
pairs hyper-iconic sex symbols Robert Mitchum and Jane Russell under
Howard Hughes' production, but also features the underrated Charles
McGraw, Raymond Burr, Tim Holt, Marjorie Reynolds, Jim Backus and
Vincent Price in one of his best acting roles. This one goes all out
in a tale about a nearly washed up gambler (Mitchum) suddenly seeing
his fortunes take a turn for the better when the deal he enters into
near the Mexican border could be fatal. This is the kind of fun,
energetic, power productions Martin Scorsese was pointing out in his
great film The
Aviator
that Hughes and only Hughes could to would dare to make. The audio
commentary by the great Vivian Sobchack is a real gem, loaded with
all kinds of facts and observations that adds to the rewatchability
of an amazing production.''
The
other extras include an Original Theatrical Trailer and Bugs Bunny
animated Technicolor short Bunny
Hugged.
Joel
Souza's
Rust
(2024) was likely on its way to becoming at least a minor classic in
the Western genre when unexpected disaster happened and
co-producer/star Alec Baldwin was creating a vital scene where he was
to shoot his gun into the point of view of the camera. Thinking the
gun was loaded with blanks, he fired, but it had a bullet and killed
Director of Photography Halyna Hutchins, A.S.C. and was one of the
most horrible things that had happened on any movie set in a while.
Baldwin even got charged with murder (for reasons we cannot go into
here, politics likely played a part) which he beat in court. Then
they had to finish the film.
Running
over two hours, this cut is a mixed bag with some of the film really
working, but others just too talky and cliched, some of which might
be ill-advised reshoots. In its current 2+ hour cut, I could have
trimmed about 20 minutes or so and this would have been a better
film. Still, Baldwin is good here and obviously saw in the original
screenplay the potential that this could work really well. The tale
has a young 13-year-old (Patrick Scott McDermott) eventually
convicted for murder to hang, as if an adult when he accidentally
shot dead a man wanting him to be a indentured worker after an
altercation with his son that the son caused.
The
set-up is not as convincing as it should have been, but having the
whole town just let that young be convicted without ANY objection
makes it worse, though this is an excuse for a mysterious strange
(Baldwin) to show up and do something about it. They both land up on
the run with a big reward for them and several people hunting them
down, including one particularly determined killer (Travis Fimmel of
Vikings)
and several members of the law.
The
problems come with scenes that are too long, too talky and a script
that has too many unnecessary cliches and still insists on retaining
them. Too bad, as this again was likely going to be a better film
before the incident, but it has just enough moments to give it a good
look if interested. Frances Fisher, Jake Busey and Xander Berkeley
head the rest of the cast.
There
are sadly no extras.
Ray
Mendoza and Alex Garland's Warfare
(2025) is one of the biggest surprises of the year, a remarkable war
film about Navy SEALS trapped in an Iraqi apartment building and how
they have to fight their way out. Smart, suspenseful, clever, vivid,
blunt, sometimes graphic and totally engrossing, A24 has yet another
ace of a film with a great cast led by Will Poulter and Michael
Gandolfini.
We
join the group in the middle of their mission, though only so much is
explained, when trouble surfaces and they are eventually under
attack. All of this happens slowly, suddenly, but not necessarily
totally unexpectedly. Then from there, they have to deal with it and
it simply builds as it gets more and more intense, as effective as
the likes of Full
Metal Jacket,
Black
Hawk Down
and other such films in the genre. I won't say anything else as to
not ruin any surprises or twists, but it is based on a true story and
is immediately one of the year's best.
Extras
include six illustrated, collectible postcards with behind-the-scenes
photography by Alex Brockdorff, while the disc adds a Feature Length
Audio Commentary with Ray Mendoza, Alex Garland, and Military
Consultant Brian Philpot and the ''Courage
Under Fire: The Making of Warfare''
featurette.
Now
for playback performance. The 2160p HEVC/H.265, 1.66 X 1, Dolby
Vision/HDR (10; Ultra HD Premium)-enhanced Ultra High Definition
image on
Barry Lyndon 4K
is one-of-a-kind visual experience, with every shot looking like a
painting, yet very alive, from the use of a custom zoom lens to make
the row of fighting soldiers look like walls, to the strict use of
candlelight to shoot interior shots, making the people look like
paintings and sometimes, death. Kubrick took a Mitchell 35mm camera,
had the lenses and plate removed, then cut wider to fit a NASA
satellite lens inside, allowing for the shots at a time when
photochemical film stocks had somewhat limited light sensitivity to
get the final image. The results are stunning, never duplicated
again and with Director of Photography John Alcott, B.S.C., the
transfer here is based off of a 2000 HD master Leon Vitali created
from Kubrick's personal notes and delivers like nothing since I saw
the film on 35mm film.
The
1080p 1.66 X 1 digital High Definition image on the regular Blu-ray
is still good, but no match for the 4K and pales at times in
comparison.
The
sound on both disc versions is here in an upgraded DTS-HD MA (Master
Audio) 5.1 lossless mix and PCM 1.0 Mono mix, the former of which I
like better but shows the limits of the original recording at times,
the latter of which is a little weaker than I would have liked it to
be and should have been 2.0 Mono instead. Of course, the 5.1 brings
out more in the music and battle scenes.
The
1080p 1.33 X 1 black & white digital High Definition image
transfers on both Suite
and Woman
can sometimes show the age of the materials used, but these transfers
are far superior to all previous home video releases of the films and
only a mint film print or 4K editions could compete now. The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Mono lossless mixes on both are as good
as the films will likely ever sound, but they are a little more
sonically limited than I would have liked and though better than
their lossy DVD versions, warmer if not a giant improvement.
Also
issued in a 4K edition we hope to see soon, the 1080p 2.00 X 1 High
Definition image transfer on Warfare
looks
good and consistent throughout, plus some very effective editing,
something we do not see enough. The lossless Dolby Atmos (Dolby
TrueHD 7.1 mixdown for older systems) mix also has its moments,
though more than a few down points for dialogue and suspense, it is
the best on the list of all the titles here.
The
anamorphically enhanced 2.35 X 1 image on Rust
has some good shots, but this older format is holding it back at its
best, then you can tell how some shots are not from the original
shoot. The best shots deserve a Blu-ray and 4K release, but you can
still appreciate it here just enough. The lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 is
also not bad, but we'd bet it is better in a lossless format.
To
order
either of the Warner Archive Blu-rays, Executive
Suite
and His
Kind Of Woman,
go to this link for them and many more great web-exclusive
releases at:
https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/ED270804-095F-449B-9B69-6CEE46A0B2BF?ingress=0&visitId=6171710b-08c8-4829-803d-d8b922581c55&tag=blurayforum-20
-
Nicholas Sheffo