
Alto
Knights (2025/Warner
Blu-ray)/Lean On Me
(1989*)/My Mother Land
(2023 aka My
Motherland/Icarus
DVD)/Never On Sunday
(1960/UA/MGM DVD)/Seed Of
The Sacred Fig (2025/Neon
Blu-ray)/Three Comrades
(1938/MGM/*both Warner Archive Blu-rays)
Picture:
B/B-/C/C+/B-/B Sound: B/B-/C/C+/B/C+ Extras: D/C-/C-/D/C-/C
Films: C+/C+/B-/C+/B-/C+
PLEASE
NOTE:
The Lean
On Me
and Three
Comrades
Blu-rays are now only available from Warner Bros. through their
Warner Archive series and can be ordered from the link below.
Barry
Levinson's Alto
Knights
(2025) has Robert De Niro in a dual role as two famous, real life
gangsters: Frank Costello and Vito Genovese. He's good here, but
even all the make-up and visual effects can only do so much to cover
up the fact that it is one of the most iconic actors in cinema
history. He still fares well enough here. With a screenplay penned
by no less than Nicholas Pileggi with Irwin Winkler as a Co-Producer,
it has its moments, but cannot help but repeat so much we have seen
in the genre as it has become more worn out than ever. It skips the
glamour of Levinson's Bugsy
and feels more like his classic Diner
or Scorsese and De Niro's gangster films to its advantage.
Unfortunately,
though I liked Scorsese's The
Irishman
(see my Criterion Blu-ray review elsewhere on this site) despite some
issues, this is more of a flipside to that film when death and aging
from survival takes over the thrill and excitement of the lifestyle
of no rules, robbery, terrorizing others and murder. Thus, it is
worth a look for fans of the genre and talents involved, but only
expect so much.
This
is still Levinson's best theatrical film in a long time, though he
has been delivering some exceptional TV and telefilms in recent
decades, so he is far from out of things to show, say and do. Debra
Messing, Michael Rispoli, Cosmo Jarvis, and Katharine Narducci also
star.
There
are sadly and oddly no extras.
John
G. Avildsen's Lean
On Me
(1989) was part of the odd 'tough teacher' cycle of movies that
included Stand
and Deliver
and Dangerous
Minds
that essentially said maybe if teachers got tough with their students
and civil rights be damned, schools could do a better job of
teaching. A Reagan-era idea that backfired in several scandals,
these movies were usually 'based on a true story' with liberties
taken.
Morgan
Freeman plays Joe Clark, with a bullhorn and baseball bat, is brought
in to 'save' a failing high school. Going in the opposite direction
of his Electric
Company
work, it was not the feel good Rocky/Karate
Kid
film Director Avildsen had become known for and the hit song (remade
here by Thelma Houston and The Wayans) land up not having the same
meaning as the original 1972 #1 Bill Withers classic hit.
Now
a curio, it is more obvious how the film does not work, but helping
is a supporting cast that boasts Lynne Thigpen, Robert Guillaume,
Beverly Todd, Alan North, Regina Taylor, Tony Todd, Michael
Imperioli, Michael Beach and Ethan Phillips. Yes, the studio backed
this as a big A-level film and it had some success. Now you can see
how it is and has aged.
An
Original Theatrical Trailer is the only extra.
Benoit
Cohen's My
Mother Land
(2023 aka My
Motherland)
stars Fanny Ardant as a wealthy elderly woman who decides to
participate in helping out an Afghan refugee (Nawid Elham) through a
program she recently heard about. Friends around her are not so sure
it is a good idea, but she sticks to her decision and the results are
more layered than you might expect.
Inspired
by a true story involving the director in real life, it can be a
slice of life film, as well as a sort of character study, but I was
surprised how naturalistic and convincing it was, not just something
obvious, cliched or trivial. Of course, its timing could not be
better considering current events.
Trailers
for other Icarus releases are the only extras.
Jules
Dassin's Never
On Sunday
(1960) is a comedy/drama about free spirited prostitute Ilya (Melina
Mercouri, in a star-making role) meeting a writer/photographer (a
very convincing Dassin) who becomes enamored with her. He is a
stranger in Greece, clueless about their culture and ways that he
tries to navigate to get to know her, so complication ensue.
Playing
a little loose with virgin/whore complex while also trying to deal
with Greek literature and philosophy, the film can be a mixed bag,
but it looks good, the actors are good and the title song (which she
sings in the film) is a classic and won the Best Song Oscar. At
least a minor classic, Dassin is best known for heist, crime, mystery
and noir films, some of which Mercouri would also appear in.
It
is worth a look and a curio also thanks to its song, which was a hit
for several people as an instrumental (Don Costa) vocal (The
Chordettes) and many others that did not chart, including Connie
Francis,
Bing Crosby, Lena Horne, Doris Day, Andy Williams, Frankie Valli &
The 4 Seasons, Julie London, Eartha Kitt, Petula Clark, Ann-Margret,
Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass and The Ventures. Yep, its that
kind of record.
There
are sadly no extras.
Mohammad
Rasoulat's The
Seed Of The Sacred Fig
(2025) is an interesting thriller and drama where Iman is made an
investigating judge in the current religious, theocratic dictatorship
of Iran, with things slowly getting worse and worse as he tries to do
his work. The screenplay does its best to make its political points,
but the behind-the-scenes twist is that this film was made on
location in total secret!
Still
an interesting thriller, this ambitious project does run a bit long
at 166 minutes (!!!) but works more often than not and is easily one
of the hardest feature film productions of the last few years. That
it works, is consistent and holds together if you put the viewing
time in means all the hard work and high risk was worth it as it
tells it like it is as well.
Of
course, the current regime destroyed most of the cinema made under
The Shaw who was overthrown in the late 1970s, with little having
been saved since. This film is a tribute to that cinema lost too.
A
Making Of featurette is the only extra.
Frank
Borzage's Three
Comrades
(1938) is a strange Post-WWI drama with three German friends (Robert
Taylor, Robert Young, Franchot Tone) intend to move on (despite their
country losing and then having severe troubles than led to WWII!)
living the best lives they can. I had problems believing the actors
were german and that the WWI events could just be dismissed as over
and they could move on.
Running
a mere 98 minutes, F. Scott Fitzgerald of all people wrote the
screenplay adaption from the Erich Maria Remarque novel and it is not
a bad film on its own, but its just a little off and always was,
despite MGM giving this one A-level treatment. Joseph L. Mankiewicz
produced and the fine supporting cast includes Guy Kibbee, Lionel
Atwill, Margaret Sullivan and Henry Hull.
Extras
include an Original Theatrical Trailer and two short films: How
To Raise A Baby and The Face Behind The Mask.
Now
for playback performance. The 1080p 2.35 X 1 digital High Definition
image on Alto
Knights
looks good, albeit with all kinds of digital work and clashing
editing, but we've seen these kinds of visuals before in many films,
including by Levinson and Scorsese. Director of Photography Dante
Spinotti, A.S.C., A.I.C., can still deliver. The
lossless Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mixdown for older systems)
sounds good, but only so spectacular as this is a dialogue-based film
despite its use of music and sound effects. The combination is fine,
but I wonder if this would be more effective in 4K.
The
1080p 1.85 X 1 digital High Definition image on Lean On Me is
from an older HD master, which has some good shots, but shows its
relatively recent age. The DTS-HD
MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Stereo lossless mix is a decent reproduction of
the film original analog Dolby System A-type Dolby Stereo sound,
which itself shows its age, maybe a little more because of the older
videomaster, but it is fine for what we get. The combination is
passable, but maybe it will get the 4K treatment later.
The
1080p 2.35 X 1 digital High Definition image transfer on Sacred
Fig is a little softer than I would have liked, though the
circumstances in which it was shot, equipment used and genre itself
might be part of the reason it has the look it has, while the
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) Persian 5.1 lossless mix sounds as good as
any film on this list, so it is some remarkable work considering.
The
1080p 1.33 X 1 black & white digital High Definition image
transfer on Comrades can sometimes show the age of the
materials used and is the oldest film on the list, but it looks as
good any anything on this list at its best. The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Mono lossless mix is limited and shows
the sonics of its age, its original theatrical monophonic sound.
However, this likely sounds as good as it ever will.
The
anamorphically enhanced 2.35 X 1 image on
Motherland
is a little softer than I would have liked, though it cannot tell us
how good this could look in even regular HD. The lossy French
Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo fares better, but also likely would sound
better lossless.
And
the anamorphically enhanced black &
white 1.66 X 1 image on Never On Sunday has some
softness in places, but looks good often enough for the older format,
while the lossy Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono in multiple languages is fine
for that older format. Guess we'll see this one in HD at some point.
To
order
either of the Warner Archive Blu-rays, Lean
On Me
and/or Three
Comrades,
go to this link for them and many more great web-exclusive
releases at:
https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/ED270804-095F-449B-9B69-6CEE46A0B2BF?ingress=0&visitId=6171710b-08c8-4829-803d-d8b922581c55&tag=blurayforum-20
-
Nicholas Sheffo