Fulvue Drive-In.com
Current Reviews
In Stores Soon
 
In Stores Now
 
DVD Reviews, SACD Reviews Essays Interviews Contact Us Meet the Staff
An Explanation of Our Rating System Search  
Category:    Home > Reviews > Thomas & Sarah (British TV Mini-series)

Thomas & Sarah (British TV mini-series)

 

Picture: C     Sound: C+     Extras: D     Episodes: B

 

 

As a follow-up to their huge DVD set of the complete Upstairs, Downstairs, A&E has released its 13-episode spin-off Thomas & Sarah.  The title characters, as played by John Alderton and Pauline Collins, is almost naughty in deciding to focus on two characters who were “lower” part of the caste system that was part of the original uppity soap opera Upstairs, Downstairs was.

 

It also was a huge surprise hit for PBS in the early days when many still considered public television somewhat of an experiment.  The huge record ratings it had stunned the Big Three networks and experts alike.  “Quality television” was not supposed to be hit TV, hip, or successful beyond a small group of adults and masses of children.  TV for a better tomorrow, which PBS still is all these decades later, had scored a moral victory about a household whose structure was immoral.

 

Ironically, the early shows were not even broadcast in the United States initially, particularly those with future Mike Gambit of The New Avengers Gareth Hunt as Frederick the Footman.  Regardless, even a smart hit is still a hit and Thomas & Sarah scared many into thinking the quality British imports might sell out.  Instead, a quality spin-off resulted, thanks to quality writing and casting, plus the careful and patient directing of John Davies.

 

Writer/producer John Shaughnessy proved that al the characters from Upstairs, Downstairs were developed enough that a few could survive on their own.  The car chauffeur and parlor maid find that life outside of the protective walls of 165 Eaton Place.  Collins is especially good as the subversive big mouth who breaks every norm that should have been struck done long ago.  She cannot stand hypocrisy and Collins is perfect in the role.  The 13 episodes are as follows:

 

1)     Birds Of A Feather

2)     The Silver Ghost

3)     The Biters Bit

4)     The Vanishing Lady

5)     Made In Heaven

6)     A Day At The Metropole

7)     The Poor Young Widow Of Peckham

8)     There Is A Happy Land

9)     Return To Gethyn

10)  Putting On The Ritz

11)  The New Rich

12)  Love Into Three Won’t Go

 

The full frame image of the PAL tapes are not in top shape, with a disclaimer on the back of the box.  This is typical of early color PAL productions such as The Sandbaggers where the tapes were new and storage problems also resulted.  This is also why U.S. TV always remade British TV, especially when it was made on tape to begin with.  Color TV came to England later a little later than the U.S. and Only PBS and syndicated TV would handle PAL-originated product.  With that said, there is tape damage here and there, with definition limits and even haloing in spots.  This is as good as this is going to look.  The sound has been reprocessed into simple Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo from the original TV mono and the result is a plus for the presentation.  The only extra is a “Household Hierarchy & Job Duties” diagram that is interactive enough to explain each.

 

The shows are interconnected in chronological order, but never run into the kind of soap opera formula lesser shows do, the way Upstairs, Downstairs managed to avoid those kinds of traps.  If that show is a TV classic, Thomas & Sarah is a very worthy follow-up.  It asks many questions about money, position and happiness that are as relevant as ever, and go even beyond the predecessor series.  Anyone who gets the chance to catch this 4-DVD set will want to yell Bravo!

 

 

-   Nicholas Sheffo


Marketplace


 
 Copyright © MMIII through MMX fulvuedrive-in.com