Justice
League: Crisis On Infinite Earths, Part Three
(2024/Blu-ray)/Super
Friends!: The Complete Collection
(1973 - 1985 aka Superfriends/Blu-ray
+ DVD Sets)/Watchmen:
Chapter One 4K (2024
animated/4K Ultra HD Blu-ray w/Blu-ray/all DC Comics/Warner)
4K
Ultra HD Picture: A- Picture: B-/B/C+/B+ Sound: B/B-/C/B+
Extras: C+ (Crisis: C) Main Programs: C/B-/B-/B+
Up
next are a new wave of animated superhero releases that are classic
or connected to classic DC Comics....
Justice
League: Crisis On Infinite Earths, Part Three (2024) concludes
the animated adaption of the classic 1985 to 1986 comic book series
that had DC Comics decide to eliminate all kinds of various versions
of their superheroes that they had been creating and innovating since
the 1930s in a bid to sell more comics, be more like Marvel and bit
and give them a boost after the Superman feature film
franchise and Super Friends! TV series had ended. We covered
the 4K versions of the first two animated versions at these links:
Part
One
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/16404/Fortunes+Of+War+(2023/101+Films+DVD)/Impuls
Part
Two
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/16449/Justice+League:+Crisis+On+Infinite+Earths+Part
Well,
my fellow critic was only so impressed and despite my admiration for
the original comic book series, for better and worse (elements of
those other worlds made comebacks later, by little surprise) but this
is four decades later, multiverses all over the place and a much-less
unique or special idea. Also, the whole DC world has changed, so all
the scripts can do is represent all the world now and re-separated
ones at that, so it just seems a bit banal and this has some of the
poorest animation art and art design I have ever seen for any DC
Comics TV/straight-to-video series since it all started with the 1966
Filmation Superman. They also toned-down the graphicness of
the art form the original comic books, further blunting any impact.
If
you must see this, read the comic books FIRST, then watch the three
films in chronological order and in 4K. Otherwise, I was very
disappointed and can see why so many are particularly disappointed
here.
Extras
include Digital Movie Code, the disc adds the featurettes: A
Multiverse of Inspiration and John and John: Stewart and
Constantine.
Super
Friends!: The Complete Collection (1973 - 1985) is a sort of
surprise release, a huge set of discs covering all 13 seasons of what
is still the longest-running animated superhero TV series of all
time, issued in a DVD set that represses all the individual DVD sets
issued over many years and introducing all the episodes on Blu-ray,
which is the biggest event of all of this. Here is our coverage of
the early seasons on DVD for you to get up to speed on things:
Season
One, Volume One
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/9421/Super+Friends!+%E2%80%93+Season+One,+Volu
Season
One, Volume Two
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/10182/Super+Friends!+%E2%80%93+Season+One,+Volu
All
New Super Friends Hour: Season One, Volume One
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/6685/The+All+New+Super+Friends+Hour+%E2%80%93
All
New Super Friends Hour: Season One, Volume Two
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/8476/The+All+New+Super+Friends+Hour:+Season+One
Super
Friends: The Lost Episodes
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/9175/Super+Friends+%E2%80%93+The+Lost+Episodes
The
show can be divided into four eras: 1) Vintage shows with Wendy,
Marvin & Wonder Dog, 2) second kids wave with The Wonder Twins
aka Zan, Jayna & Gleek era, 3) classic era concludes with new
characters added and 4) 1980s revised heroes (especially their
costumes) ushering in the new era we know still today. This was
enough to get DC to The Dark Knight Returns and the rest is
history.
So
how do they play for me? I like the first episodes and along with
the arrival of The Six Million Dollar Man as a huge hit show
with its toys and the 1977 Star Wars with its huge-selling
toys and those are the three moments in superhero/space opera/action
history that became the foundation of megahit movies and their toy
ties-ins we still live in today. Those first shows were the most
child-safe ever, to the dismay of some fans, which I understand, but
the PBS effect was in full swing by then. The second era with the
Wonder Twins was not as good teleplay wise, but they had their
moments, though where Wendy, Marvin & Wonder Dog was never
explained and that was a bad move still an issue to this day. Once
the second child duo was out of the way, we landed up with more
heroes and villains from the pages of DC and it was also a mixed bag
for me, repetitive, with uneven tales and some that were just bad. A
few good shows did turn up and the show even got darker than expected
in spots before it was finally cancelled. More than any other show,
including anything from Marvel and they did make some good animated
shows to their credit, Super
Friends
tracks the rise and changes in the genre that finally formed into one
piece with 1978's Superman:
The Movie
and live action hits like Wonder
Woman
and The Incredible
Hulk
only added to the underappreciated superhero mania of the time.
Recently,
Warner and DC have issued a few retro Super
Friends
toys and tie-ins, including new Mego-like action figures (usually
8-inches, with actual clothing and accessories on them) for all the
eras, so the show has had a sort of mini-comeback with fans, so these
new sets totally make sense. For the Blu-ray set especially, some
hardcore fans would say it is long overdue.
As
for extras, both sets retain all the extras of the old DVD sets as
linked to above, plus the Legendary Super Powers Show adds
five audio commentary tracks on select episodes, The Super Powers
Collection: The Effect Of The Toy Industry On The Super Friends
(though I could argue vice versa) and how the series was ahead of its
time I diversity with the featurette Evolution: New Heroes, Vile
Villains and Ethnic Additions. Finally. the Super Powers Team
set adds Super Friends Redux: Galactic Guardians Retrospective.
So you get no new extras, though an updated and expanded featurette
on the toys since 1973 that happened because of the show might be a
good idea.
Alan
Moore and Dave Gibbons' Watchmen is one of, if not THE most
celebrated graphic novel of all time. It has also been adapted to
visual media several times. Of course, there's the infamous Zack
Snyder 2009 film, which got things mostly right (except for changing
the last act dramatically. In conjunction with that film's release,
there was an animated tie-in film, billed then as a motion comic that
went direct to video, that was faithful to the source material, but
oddly had one male voice actor for all the characters (who even
voiced the female characters too). After the dust settled on the
property for a few years, a mostly interesting HBO series sequel of
the same name was launched to mixed responses from fans, and all of
which is reviewed elsewhere on this site.
Here
we are with yet another Watchmen animated film from Warner
Bros., Watchmen: Chapter One 4K
(2024,) this time with a bit cleaner animation which
faithfully adapts the source material and brings it to animated life.
The end result is fine. There's nothing wrong with the animation
here and they even include The Tales From The Black Freighter
subplot as it appears in the original graphic novel in a very fun
way. This being Chapter One, this is obviously the first of several
releases in the coming months.
Watchmen
Chapter I features all all-star voice cast which includes Matthew
Rhys (Dan Dreiberg, Nite Owl), Katee Sackhoff (Laurie Juspeczyk, Silk
Spectre) and Titus Welliver (Rorschach, Walter Kovacs), along with
Troy Baker (Adrian Veidt, Ozymandias), Adrienne Barbeau (Sally
Jupiter, Silk Spectre), Corey Burton (Captain Metropolis), Michael
Cerveris (Jonathan Osterman, Dr. Manhattan), Jeffrey Combs (Edgar
Jacobi, Moloch), Grey DeLisle, Kelly Hu, John Marshall Jones (Hooded
Justice), Max Koch, Phil LaMarr, Yuri Lowenthal (Wally Weaver), Geoff
Pierson (Hollis Mason, Nite Owl), Dwight Schultz, Jason Spisak, Kari
Wahlgren (Janey Slater), and Rick D. Wasserman (Edward Blake, The
Comedian).
Set
in an alternate version of America during the Cold War era, Watchmen
realizes a world with real superheroes that have done more damage to
society than good. While only one has true super powers (Dr.
Manhattan), the cast of vigilantes all bring their own complex and
hardened stories set against a ticking doomsday clock and the
horrific realities of the world they live In. When one of the
Watchmen ends up dead in a shocking murder, an investigation is
started that spirals into a heavy study into the superhero genre
unlike any other story ever has, and which is frighteningly relevant
to today's world.
Special
Features
:
The
Art of Adaptation: Introducing the Story
Dave
Gibbons and Watchmen: Chapters I-VI Featurette
While
I wouldn't say this release was necessary or really in demand by
fans, the end result passes with flying colors and should please
those new to the material or those that are thirsty for more Watchmen
content in their lives. I myself am looking forward to future
chapters!
Now
for playback performance. Watchmen:
Chapter One
is presented in 2160p on 4K UHD disc with HDR10 (Ultra
HD Premium),
an HEVC / H.265 codec, a widescreen aspect ratio of 2.39:1 and an
audio track in lossless, English DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 (48kHz,
24-bit) sound. The animation style is clean and nicely done with a
look similar to that of the original graphic novel. I would say this
is definitely a bit flashier than the motion comic feature mentioned
earlier, and falls more in line with some of Warner Bros.'
animation's other recent ambitious DC projects, if not better. It
seems more of a three dimensional, computer animated animation this
time around with clean moving shots that are sharp and nice looking.
Overall, I am impressed with the animation here - definitely more
than I expected to be.
Also
included is the animated film presented in 1080p high definition on
Blu-ray disc with an MPEG-4 AVC codec, a widescreen aspect ratio of
2.39:1 and a lossless, English DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 (48kHz,
24-bit) mix as featured on the 4K edition. The presentation is
similar, but not quite as pristine as the 4K UHD disc, but is fine
for most home entertainment set-ups.
The
1080p 1.78 X 1 digital High Definition image transfer on Justice
League is not as good as the previous releases that we received
in 4K, though some style choices hold this all back no matter what
the definition. Color also suffers and it is softer than it should
be be transfer or design. The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 lossless mix is a but better, though
nothing special, so the combination is not up to the animated DC
releases of the last few years, regardless of the format.
The
1080p 1.33 X 1 digital High Definition image transfers on the Blu-ray
set of all the Super Friends! episodes can show the age of the
shows more from the dated, limited animation than the source
materials, which look good overall and better than expected for the
earliest seasons. Filmation had made all the first DC Comics TV
animated cartoon series from 1966 (Superman) to the early
1970s when the contracts apparently ended. Hanna-Barbera had to make
a big showing and now that we can see them in HD, the first 1973
episodes have even a little more money and more work in them, though
nominal, impressive enough for its time despite other art errors all
over.
The
color continues to be good for the Wonder Twins shows and color is
not bad to the end, but seems to get slightly more limited in range
and slightly less vibrant as the animation can get courser and a
little rougher as Hanna-Barbera started to allow overseas entities to
do some, most or all of their animation. By 1977, the Filmation New
Adventures Of Batman (reviewed on Warner Blu-ray elsewhere on
this site) actually looked a little better and a little more
expensive by comparison to what ewe get here at that time.
Filmation
had Technicolor doing their lab work and prints and it shows, though
it looks that good for at least the first Super
Friends
shows, whether Warner had any dye-transfer,
three-strip Technicolor materials of these shows to work with. What
is clear is that the 13 years of 35mm camera materials were not only
stored very well, but handled and survived very well, so unless you
were somehow lucky to see a solid full color print of any of the
episodes, you have NEVER seen these shows look this good before and a
4K version of any of them would bring out more flaws in the limited
animation with better color, so who knows if we'll ever see that.
But once again, yet again,
The
sound on the Blu-ray discs are a series of DTS-HD MA (Master Audio)
2.0 Mono lossless mixes until the last Super
Powers shows, which are
in DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Stereo lossless mixes and all sound
better than their lossy versions on the old DVD of the shows that are
exactly the same as in the DVD set here. To my eternal
disappointment, most of the series on DVD was in poor, lame, lossy
Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono and even the latter, last of the shows in
lossy Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo were not that hot. The DTS version on
the Blu-rays are much more like it, especially for the early shows,
which sound even better than I thought they could and they will never
sound better.
The
1.33 X 1 image on all the DVDs are the same old transfers to, as good
as they can get for the old format, but I cannot strongly recommend
the Blu-ray set over it enough.
-
Nicholas Sheffo and James Lockhart (4K)
https://www.facebook.com/jamesharlandlockhartv/