Mulholland
Dr.
(1999/Criterion Blu-ray)/Possession
(1981/Umbrella Region Free Import Blu-ray)/Shock
(1977/Arrow*)/Stage
Fright
(1950/Warner Archive Blu-ray)/Toolbox
Murders 4K
(1978/Blue Underground 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray w/Blu-ray/*both MVD)/Wild
At Heart
(1990/Twilight Time Limited Edition Blu-ray)
4K
Ultra HD Picture: B+ Picture: A-/B+/B+/B/B/B+ Sound:
A/B+/B+/C+/B- & C+/A Extras: B/B/B/C/C+/A Films:
A-/B/C+/C+/C/A
PLEASE
NOTE:
The Possession
Import Blu-ray is now only available from our friends at Umbrella
Entertainment in Australia and can play on all 4K Blu-ray players,
Wild
At Heart
is from Twilight Time and is a limited edition limited to only 3,000
copies and is out of print (try the usual secondary market channels
to get it if you can,) while Stage
Fright
is now only available from Warner Bros. through their Warner Archive
series. All can be ordered from the links below.
Next
up are a wide variety of thrillers, including a
few helmed by legends...
With
the benefit of some serious hindsight, it's clear that Twin
Peaks
is a hinge point in David Lynch's career. Not only has it became the
singularly most resonant piece of his oeuvre for a multitude of fans,
it came to dominate and exert a heavy gravitational pull on the
filmmaker's work.
Prior
to the ABC Network series, a deconstructionist soap opera, by turns
cheesily uproarious and disturbingly spooky, that was cultural
phenomenon that blazed white hot for one season, in 1989, before
flaming out in its second (why that happened is the subject of
another essay) - Lynch established himself as a singular auteur with
films like Eraserhead
(1977), The
Elephant Man
(1980), and his masterpiece Blue
Velvet
(1986). (There is also Dune,
from 1984, which, again, another essay [see our 4K coverage elsewhere
on this site].) There are common themes that run throughout this
work - the sinister hiding just below the surface of bucolic
Americana, misfits and outcasts, a kind of twisted sense of nostalgia
- but it's hard to see them connecting to a larger narrative.
After
Lynch and co-creator Mark Frost asked America ''Who killed Laura
Palmer?'' and, in the course of refusing to solve the mystery,
established a universe of supernatural otherplaces, tulpas and
doubles, and dreams within dreams with dreams, the work Lynch
attached himself to became fixated on variations of those themes.
There's Twin
Peaks: Fire Walk With Me
(1992), of course, a fairly terrible revisionist prequel to the show,
meant to be the first of many Peaks
films, that was so reviled upon release it killed the series. (It
was only with the release of the spectacularly bizarre and
extraordinarily spectacular Twin
Peaks: The Return,
or Season
Three,
whichever you prefer, from 2014 that FWWM
is mostly redeemed, even if the new takes on characters established
in the show still feels unmotivated and needlessly prurient.) But
there's also Lost
Highway
(1997), which feels so indebted to Peaks
- from its narrative driven by a character becoming a different
person to the mysterious ghoul from somewhere beyond to the
red-curtain-and-checkerboard-floor transitional space, all part of
the Peaks grammar; that it's absurd to think it's anything but a
story set in the Peaks universe. (Indeed, Lynch only relatively
recently relented and said as much.) And Inland
Empire
(2006) is a Russian nesting doll of tulpas and double-speak and
universes overlapping one another.
Stack
the pre-Peaks
films against the ones that came after and it's impossible to ignore
how epochal the series was on Lynch and his storytelling. But if
there's any doubt, it's instructive to look at two films as kind of
nodes in Lynch's career: Wild
at Heart
(1990) and Mulholland
Dr.
(1999).
When
Wild
at Heart
debuted, it was easy to think that Lynch had reached a kind of
creative apex. The film, starring Nicolas Cage and Lynch favorite
Laura Dern as a neo-noir Romeo and Juliet - Cage, as ex-con Sailor,
wearing his Brandoest snakeskin jacket and at his Elvis-sneering
best; Dern, as Lula, in her slinky, sexy tube-top dresses all
youthful lust and gusto; the couple trying to outrun and outfox the
wily Johnnie Farragut (Harry Dean Stanton) hired by Lula's mom (Diane
Ladd) to take out Sailor and return Lula to her - is vintage Lynch,
the elements that made Blue
Velvet
such a smash evolved with whatever filter was on that earlier film
completely removed. (Also: Willem Dafoe in braces, looking like a
pomaded, bolo-wearing Beetlejuice, is pure, on-brand Lynch.) It's
unique, of course, and sensational, and a natural progression of
where Lynch was headed in his previous work. (It also won the Palme
d'Or at the 1990 Cannes Film Festival; when he returned in 1992 with
Fire
Walk With Me,
he was booed out of France.)
But
Wild
at Heart
was also something of an instant anachronism for Lynch. It was
released in the middle of the original Peaks
run and, watching it now, in context with the films that came after,
it's clear Lynch reached this height with Wild
at Heart
and chose to scale the, ahem, other peak he was ascending with Twin
Peaks.
This came from a place of creative obsession - Lynch is a restless
creator - but you can argue resentment played as much a part in the
choice.
Completing
Wild
at Heart
pulled Lynch off Twin
Peaks,
giving ABC the opening to flex its muscle and demand Lynch and Frost
wrap up the mystery meant to remain forever unsolved, lest the
audience get bored. Once this happened, early in Season Two, the
show falters, becomes an actual soap opera (and a lousy one at that,)
sheds viewers, and leads to its untimely end. Even Lynch returning
for the final third of the season, and ending the series on the most
epic of cliffhangers, wasn't enough to save it from the studio axe.
For a story that so intrigued and consumed Lynch, it's hard to fault
him from seeing anything that diverted his attention from it as
detrimental.
And
so we get the second, Peaks-dominated
half of Lynch's career and it's high point, Mulholland
Dr.
Originally conceived as a Peaks
spinoff, sending Audrey Horne (Sherilyn Fenn) to Hollywood, the film
similarly began as a TV project. Starring Laura Harring as amnesiac
starlet Rita and Naomi Watts as Betty, a fresh-faced new arrival to
La La Land, the pair meet, hit it off (like, really hit it off), and
set out to solve the mystery of who Rita is and what caused her
memory loss. It's a story shot through with crime, the supernatural,
doubles, mystery, soap opera dramatics, and biting satire. If this
isn't Twin Peaks 2.0, it's definitely a spin on the idea with a much
larger budget. And, like Peaks,
it can feel disjointed, incomplete, and obtuse. That's because it
was shot as a pilot - for ABC, of all networks - that wasn't picked
up. Rather than abandon it, Lynch completed Mulholland
Dr.
as a feature, and the narrative schism this creates is both
blindlingly obvious and thrillingly daring, the break point coming
when Rita, searching for truths, gets lost in/sucked into a mystery
object. (Lynch also shot a version of the Peaks
pilot as a feature, in case it didn't make it to series, which now
lives on as home video bonus content.) It's hard to say Mulholland's
mysteries are solved - they are, sort of, but they just create more
complications - but by making it a feature film, Lynch creates a
singular examination of identity, narrative, power, and perspective.
And it's stuffed full of scenes and moments that lodge themselves in
your subconscious: ''No hay banda.'' ''This is the girl.'' The
tiny-head-giant-body studio executive behind glass. The mysterious
cowboy. Rita and Betty's psycho-sexual co-dependency. The ultimate
fate of Betty's double and how it loops the film in on itself, like a
Moebius strip.
Mulholland
Dr.
is disconcerting, as many of Lynch's films are, but in the
emotionally existential vein of Twin
Peaks
rather than, say, the relatively more straightforwardly psychological
Blue
Velvet.
Who is telling this story? How are we supposed to engage with this
film? Where should our allegiances lie? Who are these people? Who
are we? And what does how we watch this film - and what we project
onto it - say about the truths and fictions we build our sense of
self around? Sure, all great cinematic art prompts such
introspection. But Lynch achieves a depth of this exploration that
is as rare as it is sinister. These questions have haunted
discussion of Mulholland
Dr.
for more than 20 years, which has allowed it to enter the discussion
of best films of that decade - despite a fair number of viewers
throwing up their hands at what they saw as an impenetrable obtuse
piece of filmmaking. And for anyone who watched and obsessed over
Twin
Peaks: The Return
- I am firmly in this camp - it's easy to see in Mulholland
Dr.
both a continuation of previous Peaks
lore and the template for extending into more abstract, dreamy, and
narratively complex directions.
Wild
at Heart
and Mullholland
Dr.
are both superlative films, but it's difficult to watch them without
feeling some pangs. In Heart's
case, it's regret for the stories we didn't get once Lynch became
subsumed by the Twin
Peaks
mythology and universe-building. With Mulholland, it's something
like exasperation for Lynch continuing to bang this narrative of
metaphysical alternate realities. That might be why The
Straight Story
(1999), the story of an old man using his riding mower to get to
reconcile with his long-estranged brother and the ultimate outlier in
Lynch's filmography still feels so welcome and comforting. It's a
mix of out-and-out sincerity and deeply-coded social criticism that
few filmmakers would dare try, let alone pull off. That both it and
Mullholland
Dr.
were released in the same year is a powerful confirmation of Lynch's
powers and prowess as a storyteller and filmmaker. I would gladly
sacrifice another jaunt into the Black Lodge if it meant getting more
of Lynch the social critic.
That
said, I'll never complain about something David Lynch releases. His
is a singular voice in American movies, and whatever he touches is
bound to generate deep conversation and years of introspection. (On
this point, I'm not kidding: Not a day goes by that I don't think
about some element of Twin
Peaks: The Return
or some moment from Blue
Velvet
slips free from my subconscious.) When Inland
Empire
was released, Lynch attached a short intro to the theatrical
presentation that ended with him telling audiences, ''I hope you have
a good experience.'' Wild
at Heart
might be an endpoint and Mulholland
Dr.
might be a second career peak, but they were, are, and always will be
good experiences.
Thankfully,
we have exceptional home video releases of both films to ensure that
fact. Wild
at Heart
(in its original 2.35 X 1 frame) has seen two Blu-ray releases, most
recently from Shout Select in 2018. The first, and the better,
though, is the now long-out-of-print edition from Twilight Time. It
has loads of extras - ''Love,
Death, Elvis & Oz: The Making of Wild
at Heart,''
an EPK feature from 1990, extended interviews, a couple Lynch-focused
pieces, 4 TV spots, and an isolated music and effects track - and a
fairly good audio presentation in a DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1
lossless mix. Visually, the disc is solid, relying on a
Lynch-approved transfer. But it's old, dating from 2004. It's
generally strong, but with some soft spots and grain it could
certainly use an upgrade.
Shout's
disc is essentially the same as Twilight Time's, except it has a new
interview with Barry Gifford, author of the novel the film is based
on, and it's missing the isolated audio track, one of Twilight Time's
signature extras and a cool bonus that's unique enough to miss.
For
Mulholland
Dr.,
The Criterion Collection has the film (in its original 1.85 X 1
frame), guaranteeing an ideal package. (I love that Criterion has
been caring for Lynch's films; I just wish we'd get Lost
Highway
and Inland
Empire,
which desperately need exemplary discs.) Now available in a 4K
edition, we looked at the Lynch-approved Blu-ray, which has a bunch
of extras - interviews with cast and crew, on-set footage, a deleted
scene and trailer - but feels relatively light given its pedigree and
vintage. But the technical side more than picks up the slack. Given
Lynch's perfectionism, its video and audio presentations are superb,
a 4K digital transfer, supervised by Lynch and director of
photography Peter Deming and a 5.1 surround DTS-HD master soundtrack.
For a film that lives and dies on its audio presentation,
especially, it's a great mix.
Next
up, number eleven in Umbrella's Beyond
Genres
releases, others have which have been reviewed on this site
elsewhere, is Andrzej Zulawski's icon horror study of a film:
Possession
(1981), which stars Isabelle Adjani (who won big at Cannes for her
performance here), Sam Neill, Margit Carstensen. This great release
which presents the film uncut is packed with four hours of bonus
features and a solid presentation. This film is comparable to
Cronenberg in terms of weirdness levels and will either entertain you
or repulse you depending on your film tastes.
Set
in Poland, a Spy Mark (Neill) comes back to his wife (Adjani) who
wants a divorce after having an affair and is harboring dark secrets.
As he investigates further, he realizes that she has a bizarre
sexual secret that certainly is far from normal.
Possession
is presented in 1080p high definition with a widescreen aspect ratio
of 1.78:1 and a lossless 2.0 Mono DTS-HD MA mix, both of which are of
the norm for the format. The film is masterfully photographed and
really makes the audience feel uneasy in many instances. I haven't
seen other editions of the film to compare it to, but for a non 4K
release this looks pretty good.
Special
Features:
Feature
Length Audio Commentary Track with Director Andrzej Zulawski
a
second Feature Length Audio Commentary Track with Co-writer Frederic
Tuten
The
Other Side of the Wall: The Making of Possession
Interview
with with Director Andrzej Zulawski
US
Cut of Possession
Repossessed
- featurette on the US Cut of Possession
A
Divided City
- Location Featurette
The
Sounds of Possession
- Interview with Composer Andrzej Zulawski
Our
friend in the West
- Interview with Producer Christian Ferry
Basha
- Poster Analysis Featurette
International
Theatrical Trailer
and
a US Theatrical Trailer.
From
Italian horror masterminds Mario Bava and Lamberto Bava comes Shock
(1977), which was also known as Beyond
the Door 2
in its American release. While Beyond
the Door
was more of an Exorcist
knock off, this is more of a supernatural ghost possession story when
a little boy (David Colin Jr., Beyond
the Door)
is possessed by the spirit of his deceased father who lashes out at
his mother (played by Daria Nicolodi of Deep
Red),
who has moved on to another man (John Steiner, Tenebrae).
The kid really becomes a bigger and bigger brat as the film
progresses and starts to use voodoo on his parents in many scenes.
Sometimes she gets attacked by ghosts too, including one sequence
where a ghost threatens her with a knife and cuts her blouse.
Shock
is presented on Blu-ray disc with an MPEG-4 AVC (33.99 Mbps) codec, a
widescreen aspect ratio of 1.85:1, and Italian (with English
subtitles) and a lossless, English DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) Mono mix.
This is from a 2K restoration of the original 35mm film elements,
and the film looks and sounds fantastic here. The colors are really
vibrant and there's no gripes concerning the presentation considering
the limitations of the format. The soundtrack is pretty fun and is
in synth based Italian horror sounding, which adds to the film and
doesn't subtract.
Special
Features include:
New
audio commentary by Tim Lucas, author of Mario
Bava: All the Colors of the Dark
A
Ghost in the House,
a new video interview with co-director and co-writer Lamberto Bava
Via
Dell'Orologio 33,
a new video interview with co-writer Dardano Sacchetti
The
Devil Pulls the Strings,
a new video essay by author and critic Alexandra Heller-Nicholas
Shock!
Horror!
- The Stylistic Diversity of Mario Bava, a new video appreciation by
author and critic Stephen Thrower
The
Most Atrocious Tortur(e),
a new interview with critic Alberto Farina
Italian
theatrical trailer
4
US "Beyond
the Door II"
TV spots
Image
gallery
Reversible
sleeve featuring original and newly commissioned artwork by
Christopher Shy
and
First
Pressing Only:
Illustrated collector's booklet featuring new writing on the film by
Troy Howarth, author of The
Haunted World of Mario Bava
Shock
is an interesting ghost story even though it may not be the best ever
told. It showcases from interesting work from the late filmmaker
Mario Bava that fans of his work will appreciate in this Arrow
release.
Alfred
Hitchcock's Stage
Fright
(1950) is one of his comical murder thrillers that he made at his
brief-but-interesting stint at Warner Bros. after his Selznick
contract expired, this film being one of the three
independently-produced Transatlantic Pictures projects before teaming
up with the studio. It was a good period that even produced a few
classics, but this film is not one of them, though the more you watch
and understand who was cast, the more interesting it gets.
Richard
Todd plays a man having an affair with a popular singer/actress
(Marlene Dietrich in an interesting turn) when her husband turns up
dead and he is accused of the murder. He confides in a newer actress
(Jane Wyman) who believes he is innocent and even pretends to be a
housekeeper for the big star to find out the truth and help him.
Unexpectedly, a detective named Smith (Michael Wilding) starts
questioning her as she tries to avoid him to do her own
investigation, but she starts to fall for him!
The
result is a film that has its moments, but does not always add up to
having the kind of impact one would expect from Hitchcock's best
films, but not for a lack of trying or a great supporting cast that
also includes Alastair Sim (known as one of the best actors ever to
play Scrooge even then,) Sybil Thorndyke, Kay Walsh, Andre Morell,
Patricia Hitchcock and uncredited turns by Alfie Bass and Lionel
Jeffries, so everyone wanted to be in a Hitchcock film and he got
quite the cast here as a result.
At
least this is ambitious and tries to bring all the usual Hitchcockian
elements together, so it is something to celebrate that Warner
Archive has created such a fine restoration and preservation of the
film for Blu-ray as they have for a few other gems of his they
already own. Even with some off parts, everyone should see this film
at least once.
The
1.33 X 1 black & white digital High Definition image transfer
rarely shows the age of the materials used, but this is far superior
a transfer to all previous releases of the film. Director of
Photography Wilkie
Cooper, B.S.C. (First
Men In The Moon,
Hammerhead,
Green
For Danger,
Jason
& The Argonauts,
3
Worlds Of Gulliver,
Mysterious
Island,
TV's The
Avengers)
later became known for his color cinematography, but could handle
monochrome just as well and just as easily. Dietrich actually
convinced Hitchcock and Cooper to add input into how she was lit,
which is unusual, but that worked as well. Glad to see it looking so
good, but it is a Hitchcock film after all.
The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Mono lossless mix remasters the original
theatrical mono sound as well as possible, with the music sounding a
little better than the dialogue, with this now sounding the best it
likely ever will.
Extras
include a Making Of featurette and an Original Theatrical Trailer.
Last
and least to some, Dennis Donnelly's The
Toolbox Murders 4K
(1978) still tends to shock people with its blatant exploitation as
part of a cycle of such films that arrived into the 1980s that
started in the late 1960s and especially early 1970s. Now, it is
getting the 4K disc release from Blue Underground in a new 4K Ultra
HD Blu-ray w/Blu-ray set. We reviewed their older Blu-ray edition at
this link:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/10883/Embodiment+Of+Evil+(2008/Coffin+Joe+series/Sy
Though
so much more violent, graphic and blatantly bloody feature films (and
a few TV shows for that matter) have arrived, even since we reviewed
the last version, it still remains disturbing and the lack of a
strong script is even more apparent, using its name stars to be
additionally shocking (Whatever
Happened To Baby Jane?
And the original Omen
helped make that possible) but landed up derailing Ferdin's career a
bit and only helped the others to do so much.
The
only other thing that is odder is that everyone who is killed is
listening to soft, comfy, Country Pop, a cycle that was just giving
way to a new generation of Country Music via new stars and the
massive success of the hit film Urban
Cowboy
and its soundtrack, making this film still very much a product of the
1970s, albeit the very end of it. Guess Disco and Rock did not
appeal to all those victims by coincidence.
So
that leaves playback performance. The 1080p 1.66 X 1 regular Blu-ray
is the same and looks the same, so could the 2160p HECV/H.265, 1.66 X
1, Dolby Vision/HDR (10; Ultra HD Premium)-enhanced Ultra High
Definition image on the 4K edition really look that much better for a
film that wanted to look grainy and dirty often? Surprisingly, yes.
Not all the shots benefit as much as others, but there are instances
where this looks better than anyone could have ever thought it could
and the local bar interiors really benefit now that the Video Black
can be handled better with all its color. Thus, this is a surprise
in a few ways and the best way to watch this film, making it age
better, yet oddly since so much has aged otherwise. You even get a
few demo shots above my grade.
The
4K edition repeats the same lossless soundtrack options, but
surprisingly adds Dolby Atmos lossless (Dolby TrueHD 7.1 for older
systems) to the DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 and DTS-HD MA (Master
Audio) 2.0 Mono mixes we heard before. It is not an outright
improvement on the old theatrical monophonic sound or DTS upgrades,
but it opens the sound up a bit more, if not always working and being
convincing. The result is that you get a 4K-exclusivce choice to see
if you can hear and/or experience the film better in Atmos. Oncer
again, Blue Underground leaves no stone unturned.
Extras
repeat the previous
Blu-ray releases' Original Theatrical Trailers, TV & Radio Spots,
''I Got Nailed'' interview with star Marianne Walter and a feature
length audio commentary by Producer Tony DiDio, Director of
Photography Gary Graver and Pamela Ferdin. New extras are many and
include NEW! Audio Commentary #2 with Film Historians Troy Howarth
and Nathaniel Thompson
NEW!
Drill
Sergeant:
Interview with Director Dennis Donnelly
NEW!
Tools
Of The Trade:
Interview with Star Wesley Eure
NEW!
Flesh
And Blood:
Interview with Actress Kelly Nichols
NEW!
Slashback
Memories:
David Del Valle Remembers Cameron Mitchell
NEW!
'They
Know I Have Been Sad':
Video Essay by Film Historian Amanda Reyes and Filmmaker Chris
O'Neill
and
NEW! Poster & Still Gallery.
To
order the Umbrella
Possession
import Blu-ray, go to this link:
http://www.umbrellaent.com.au/
...and
to order the Stage
Fright
Warner Archive Blu-ray, go to this link for them and many more great
web-exclusive
releases at:
https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/ED270804-095F-449B-9B69-6CEE46A0B2BF?ingress=0&visitId=6171710b-08c8-4829-803d-d8b922581c55&tag=blurayforum-20
-
Nicholas Sheffo (4K, Hitchcock,) Dante A. Ciampaglia (Lynch) and
James Lockhart
https://www.facebook.com/jamesharlandlockhartv/