And
Then We Danced
(2019/Music Box Blu-ray)/Il
Trovatore/Verdi/Morandi
(2019/Zeffirelll/C Major/Unitel*)/Mahler
Symph. No 2 ''Resurrection''/Dudamel
(2019/Unitel*)/The Mother
(2019/Opus Arte*)/Simon
Boccanegra/Verdi/Gergiev
(2019/Unitel*)/Turandot/Puccini/Luisotti
(2018/BelAir*)/Yo-Yo Ma:
The Bach Project Cello Suites
(2019/C Major/*all Naxos Blu-rays)
Picture:
B- Sound: B/B/B/C+/B/B/B Extras: B-/C/C/C+/C/C/C+ Main
Programs: C+/B-/B-/C+/C+/B-/B
Now
for another large set of classical music releases...
We
start with our single theatrical feature film, Levan Akin's And
Then We Danced
(2019) has Merab
(Levan Gelbakhiani)
working at his best as a top dancer (he hopes) in the Georgian
tradition (the film takes place there) with high hopes, a girlfriend
and great potential, but the also has a few private things he is
trying to deal with. When a new dancer arrives and has the talent,
plus more ambition than he, he feels the competition. He also starts
to have feelings for him.
This
kind of story has been done before, though the Georgian background
and good actors make it something a little different, but I thought
the film was a bit uneven and did not add up to too much we have not
seen before. Still, those interested will like the more interesting
parts and that might make it worth a look for that crowd.
Next,
we revisit the Verdi classic Il
Trovatore
(2019) for the first time in many, many years, but this time, it is
directed by no less than big screen movie director Franco Zeffirelll.
We loved an earlier version by Brian Large and company that was an
early HD classical triumph we reviewed at this link:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/7439/Giuseppe+Verdi%E2%80%99s+Il+Trovatore+(Blu-r
Produced
in the outdoor Arena di Verona, it runs a long-but-pleasant 157
minutes and has its moments, though I still like the older version a
bit better. Conductor Pier Giorgio Morandi does a solid job of
keeping this colorful version going, as well as a cast that includes
Luca Salsi, Anna Netrebko, Yusif Eyvazov and Dolora Zajick, then you
get a top rate show that is one of the best entries on this list.
In
speaking of revisiting, it is always great to see the name of
composer Gustavo Dudamel, so here it is again, this time with the
Munchner Philharmoniker playing (with beautiful surroundings) Mahler
Symphony No 2: ''Resurrection''
(2019) is a performance worthy of the Abbado
version on Blu-ray a good while ago:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/10387/King+Roger+(C-Major/Unitel)+++Abbado+%E2%8
This
new one comes close, but I think Abbado's version has just the
slightest edge in how it works, but it is very thin. Fans might want
to try the two back to back and judge for themselves, but both are
more than worthy of the original work. It is a pleasant surprise
just the same.
Next
up is The
Mother
(2019) choreographed by Arthur Pita, who also directs the ballet
adaption of a Hans Christian Andersen tale, it is dark, expressive,
different, a little deathly and a little deconstructive. Starring
Natalia Osipova in the title role, it can sometimes be like a horror
film, but that is not always bad. However, it runs a surprisingly
short 78 minutes and may not be for everyone. I had a tech issue
with it, which you can read more about below.
Back
to revisiting past works, this time its Verdi's Simon
Boccanegra
(2019) conducted by Valery Gergiev and staged by Andreas Kriegenburg,
but this is very deconstructionist and minimalist with simple sets
and an abundance of texting, which the production gets too carried
away with at the expense of telling the story to me. Running a long
142 minutes, I thought the cast was not bad and even features Luca
Salsi from the Il Trovatore production above, so he is on a streak of
his own. I just wish this had expanded into other territory before
it got stuck.
I
much preferred the Mariotti
version you can read more about on Blu-ray here:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/10277/Mussorgsky+&+Borodin+%E2%80%93+Berlin+Phil
Continuing
our revisiting theme, we have Puccini's Turandot
(2018) directed by Robert Wilson with conductor Nicola Luisotti and
the Orchestra and Chorus of Teatro Real doing a nice job of
delivering an only somewhat limited-in-sets version that is actually
not bad and holds up after 122 minutes. I like the singing, use of
color and stars Irene Theorin, Gregory Kunde, Yolanda Auyanet and
Andrea Mastroni to create a solid version that works for the most
part.
It
compares well to the Chen
Kaige
version with composer Zubin
Mehta
we reviewed on Blu-ray here, which I liked a little more than the new
one:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/9307/Humperdinck%E2%80%99s+Hansel+&+Gretel/Bare
Again,
they make a great pair to compare and are impressive, so you can see
both now if you wish and in either case, you will not be
disappointed.
Finally,
last but not least, the best release on the list. Yo-Yo
Ma: The Bach Project Cello Suites
(2019) has the musician/genius deliver all six parts of the Bach
classic in a great 140-minutes-long concert that has energy, a great
audience and the master at the peak of his powers delivering
definitive performances of these classics. Simple, amazing, direct,
smooth, joyous and impressive, you can see why he continues to be one
of the most sought-after musicians in the world.
You
would think this might get repetitive or monotonous, but it does not
because he takes his time to play these pieces deeply, well and like
no one else in the world. It is fine and highly recommended, as is
this Blu-ray with Yo-Yo Ma and Mariss Jansons that is just as
impressive and impactful:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/15292/Le+Comte+Ory+(2015/Rossini/Blu-ray+++DVD)/J
The
lesson from this, Yo-Yo Ma cannot release enough Blu-rays. And
looking back at our long list of classical reviews, not enough Bach
and certainly not enough Cello.
Now
for playback performance. The 1080p 1.85 X 1 digital High Definition
image on Dance should be the best performer here, but it has motion
blur issues a little too often and lands up being as blurry in small
bits as all six Naxos 1080i 1.78 X 1 digital High Definition image
transfers, though Trovatore, Mahler and Boccanegra
claim to be 4K Ultra HD productions. Too bad they are not here on 4K
disc. Some can be a little darker than I would have liked, but the
Yo-Yo Ma disc looks best because the camera moves around the
least.
All
seven Blu-rays offer DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 lossless mixes,
save 5.0 on Yo-Yo
Ma,
but that sounds as good as anything here. All six Naxos also offer
PCM 2.0 Stereo mixes for older systems, but none work as well as
their DTS multi-channel counterparts, save Mother,
which is very harsh and shrill in either soundtrack version, a rare
miss of Naxos releases.
Extras
in all six Naxos releases include multi-lingual booklets on the
respective programs, Mahler
and Boccanegra
only add trailers, Mother
has a behind the scenes clip and Yo-Yo
Ma
has a nice on camera interview with the an himself. Dance
offers a Director Interview, Q&A piece, feature length audio
commentary track, a Dance Party, Georgian Dance Tutorial and Original
Theatrical Trailer.
-
Nicholas Sheffo